For context I am a big Apple fan and not coming here just to hate. I’m also fairly embedded in the ecosystem with an Apple TV, AirPods, Mac, iPhone, etc.

I bought the HomePods per a recommendation from a friend and ever since I’ve regretted not just buying a sound bar instead. My list of grievances:

  • I’d expect plug in speakers at the size, price, and needing to get plugged into be louder and have more bass.
  • Nonstop connectivity issues that aren’t user friendly. Sometimes there’s a lag in connecting, sometimes I need to plug it out and plug it back in, sometime I want to connect to just my HomePods and not my Apple TV, and sometimes I want to be able to disconnect easily. Yes most of these things are doable but none of them are easy.
  • Even with an Apple TV I can’t play things like my Xbox audio through the HomePods because of no eArc and an older tv
  • This one isn’t technically Apple’s fault but serious lag with Spotify. Skipping songs or fast forwarding ads on podcasts is a pain

I honestly expected a lot more from Apple given the emphasis on quality and that I was paying a premium on these speakers. Had I known all of these friction points I would’ve opted for a Sony soundbar instead

  • macbrett@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    11 months ago

    Homepods are not a good substitute for a quality sound bar or actual home stereo. I think of them as a higher fidelity substitute for a table radio intended for playing background music and not for serious listening.

    If Apple has mislead people to expect more that that, they have done a disservice.

    • HiImTheNewGuyGuy@alien.topBEnglish
      1·
      11 months ago

      My bedroom tv shares a wall with the toddler’s crib on the other side.

      Homepods allow me to put the speakers much closer to the bed so the wife and I get the volume and not the toddler.

      If you have specific needs for a secondary audio setup, homepods offer some amazing benefits. I love mine and the wife is super happy with the setup.